£50m Price Tag Raises Questions, but Mbeumo Shows Grit – Newcastle United Transfer Verdict
Newcastle Target Brentford’s Bryan Mbeumo, but High Asking Price Could Be a Stumbling Block
Newcastle United have been linked with Brentford winger Bryan Mbeumo ahead of the summer transfer window.
The Cameroon international has already shown glimpses of his quality against the Magpies, scoring in their recent 2-1 defeat and previously troubling their defence in the Carabao Cup and a 4-2 win in December.
With 38 goals and 26 assists in 128 Premier League appearances, Mbeumo has proven himself in England’s top flight.
However, Brentford are reportedly demanding £50 million for the 25-year-old, raising questions about whether Newcastle, constrained by PSR and FFP rules, should commit to such a hefty investment.
Writers at The Chronicle weighed in on the matter.
Lee Ryder believes Mbeumo fits Eddie Howe’s project, praising his resilience and consistency, even if his recent performances at St James’ Park haven’t been outstanding.
He views Mbeumo as a strong candidate who would be motivated to prove himself at a bigger club.
Ciaran Kelly considers Mbeumo a reliable option due to his experience and growth in the Premier League.
However, he suggests that Newcastle might explore younger, more affordable alternatives such as PSV’s Johan Bakayoko.
He commended Mbeumo’s composure and leadership, especially in confidently taking a penalty amid pressure during their recent match.
Stuart Jamieson agrees Mbeumo would strengthen Newcastle’s first team and ticks many boxes: he’s Premier League-proven, productive, and hardworking.
Yet, he admits the £50 million valuation is steep, though likely necessary given the scarcity of quality options.
Matt Hewitt argues that Mbeumo would be a valuable addition, particularly for bolstering the right side of Newcastle’s attack.
However, he questions the feasibility of spending over £50 million, given the club’s financial limitations, suggesting such a fee might be Newcastle’s upper limit for major signings.
Ross Gregory, meanwhile, is more cautious, noting that while Mbeumo is a quality player, there may be higher-upside targets available, such as Johan Bakayoko or Luis Henrique, who—though less proven—could offer greater long-term potential.
In summary, while Mbeumo is a strong, Premier League-tested option, opinions are split on whether his price tag aligns with Newcastle’s financial strategy and long-term goals.
