“Opinion: Dyche Might Have to Start Everton Star Following Recent Developments; His Moment Is Now”
"Sean Dyche Should Start Jake O’Brien Instead of Michael Keane to Give Everton a Chance Against Newcastle United on Saturday (October 5)"
The Blues face a significant setback ahead of their match at Goodison Park, with reports indicating that Jarrad Branthwaite will miss the game due to a minor muscle injury, as noted by The Mirror.
This disappointing news follows his first appearance of the season in last weekend’s 2-1 victory over Crystal Palace, which was hindered by a previous injury.
During Branthwaite’s absence, Michael Keane partnered with James Tarkowski, contributing to a five-match winless streak during which they conceded 14 Premier League goals.
Realistically, Keane’s return to the starting lineup could make things challenging for the Toffees even before kickoff.
Instead, manager Sean Dyche should consider making a bold decision by giving Jake O’Brien his first Premier League start against Newcastle, placing his trust in the summer signing.
This is O’Brien’s chance to demonstrate his capabilities.
Branthwaite’s return to action directly correlated with Everton achieving their first Premier League win of the season, making his absence a significant blow for the team as they aim to secure back-to-back league victories.
This situation complicates Dyche’s game plan.
Keane has not consistently performed at the required level for Everton, and his propensity for errors has proven costly on multiple occasions.
Even though Newcastle might be without Alexander Isak for the match at Goodison Park, Keane is likely to struggle against their attacking threat.
Fans would prefer to see a young prospect paired with Tarkowski rather than rely on Keane.
Dyche’s persistent reliance on his former Burnley defender could jeopardize his position if he continues this approach.
With Ben Godfrey and Mason Holgate having left the club this summer, O’Brien was brought in to strengthen the defense.
Considering the £17 million investment for his signature, viewing him as the fourth-choice centre-back at Goodison Park is unreasonable.
While O’Brien’s effectiveness remains to be seen, the potential for his success presents a better option compared to the guaranteed mediocrity Everton would face if Keane starts on Saturday.
