“Journalist Highlights Everton Issue as ‘Reckless’ Defender Continues to Struggle”

James Tarkowski, 31, has been a fixture in Everton’s defense this season, starting all 10 Premier League games, often partnering with Michael Keane due to Jarrad Branthwaite’s injury.

However, he’s received three yellow cards, including two in the last two games, and his form has raised questions about his fitness and confidence.

On the Royal Blue podcast (4 November), Thomas shared his concerns, suggesting Tarkowski may be struggling physically.

“Tarkowski has been working through fitness issues, which is concerning.

We’re seeing him make decisions he wouldn’t have made in the last two years,” he said.

Thomas speculated that the defender’s struggles might stem from either fitness issues, confidence, or the absence of Branthwaite beside him.

He pointed out specific instances, such as a rough tackle on Cameron Archer that, while not a red card, was “an awful challenge.”

Similarly, Tarkowski conceded a penalty against Newcastle’s Sandro Tonali with a “reckless” tackle, and he recently made a forceful but clean challenge on Crystal Palace’s Jean-Philippe Mateta.

Thomas suggested Tarkowski might be feeling pressured to play a more aggressive, enforcer-like role in the team.

This dip in form is reflective of Everton’s overall defensive struggles.

Sean Dyche’s team has conceded the seventh-highest number of goals in the league so far, a stark contrast to their impressive defensive record last season, when only Manchester City, Liverpool, and Arsenal allowed fewer goals.

Branthwaite’s absence has likely contributed to the team’s challenges in defense.

Tarkowski’s form has become a concern for Dyche, as the defender seems a far cry from the composed, assertive player he was last season.

Known for his calmness and leadership at the back, Tarkowski has been reliable for Everton, but his recent performances have been more problematic.

Following Everton’s 1-0 loss to Southampton on 2 November, it’s evident that adjustments are necessary.

With Everton only four points above the relegation zone, Dyche faces mounting pressure to address the defense’s issues and find a solution to help Tarkowski and the rest of the backline regain stability.